
RFK Jr. and Kid Rock in a health video
From the Ultimate Fighting Championship matches at the White House in June to President Trump's tough, acerbic talk, to Robert Kennedy Jr. and Kid Rock going shirtless and playing macho men in a health video, the conservative MAGA movement has suggested it has cornered the market on masculinity — not the wimpy Democrats.
But Pulitzer Prize winner Robin Givhan, a native Detroiter and former staffer for the Detroit Free Press and Washington Post, tackles the complex societal issue of U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's masculinity and his pushback against foes on the right in a story in the Washington Sun titled, "The Complicated Masculinity of Abdul El-Sayed."
Givhan, known for her keen sociological eye, begins her story by talking about El-Sayed meeting up with influencer Hasan Piker at Hype Recreation Center in Dearborn Heights, where the buff duo lifted weights together more than a year ago. (See video below)

Abdul El-Sayed pumping iron with Hasan Piker
"When the two finally put their weights down, Piker stopped in front of a mirror to flex his guns and encouraged El-Sayed to join him in showing off for the viewers," Givhan writes, adding that El-Sayed jokingly said, "“It’s not that kind of show, man. I want them to want me for my policy.”
She writes that the fit El-Sayed, often seen in his trademark form-fitting black T-shirts, has posted other videos and images of him working out.
She goes on to write:
Essentially, El-Sayed is using his ability to pump significant amounts of iron to send the message that progressive politics shouldn’t be equated with weakness. He is articulating and embodying a muscular form of liberalism — one that is impolite, unapologetic, and jacked. More than any other contemporary politician, he is trying to reclaim masculinity for the left. Is that a good thing? It’s gratifying, certainly. But it’s also complicated.

President Trump welcomed UFC fighters before the June matches at the White House
Givhan notes that El-Sayed learned at a young age to pushback against bullies. Trump has mocked his name, Vice President J.D. Vance has referred to him as “very, very evil,” and Republican Sen. Tommy Tuberville of Alabama has called him a “Terrorist" and "Radical Islamist."
El-Sayed doesn't hesitate to punch back against polticians like Trump and Vance with biting retorts to their attacks, showing he's no wimp. “I think they’re learning very quickly that I give better than I get," he recently told another reporter at the Washington Sun.
But Givhan warns of the potential for El-Sayed of becoming no better than his MAGA foes when flexing his masculinity, writing:
It’s all too easy to fall into the MAGA masculinity trap. When El-Sayed calls the vice president “eyeliner JD Vance,” is he striking a blow against a bully, or is he just using taunting, gendered language in service to his own bullying? Or consider when he mocks Vance’s relationship with his wife, Usha, and then Vance retaliates by warning El-Sayed to “keep my wife’s name the hell out of your mouth” — reminiscent of what Will Smith said at the 2022 Oscars after he performed toxic masculinity by storming on stage and slapping Chris Rock in the face. Did El-Sayed win a victory for liberalism in this exchange? Or did he simply descend into the most immature version of schoolyard masculinity with each side bringing out the worst in the other?
She also writes:
But in his effort to reclaim masculinity for the left, he should take care not to bring the toxicity along with it. Otherwise, he might be standing up to right-wing masculinity, but he’s not proving that he’s the better man.
The Washington Sun officially launched last Wednesday and includes more than two dozen former Washington Post journalists.






