Andrew Shirvell

The U.S. Court of Appeals delivered a mixed decision in the appeal by Andrew Shrivell, the former state assistant attorney general who was fired after waging an anti-gay campaign against a University of Michigan college student Chris Armstrong.

You might recall in August 2012, Shrivell lost in court in a civil suit and a jury ordered him to pay Armstrong $4.5 million for defamation and emotional stress. Armstrong was an openly gay former student government president at U of M.

Robert Snell of the Detroit News reports that the federal appeals panel Monday slashed the $4.5 million judgment by $1 million but denied the overall appeal in the case.

Snell writes:

Shirvell, a UM alumnus, had created the Chris Armstrong Watch blog, calling him "a radical homosexual activist, racist, elitist and liar." He had cast the blog as speech protected by the First Amendment.

Read more: Detroit News