Exchanges between The Detroit News' opinion editor and the city council's No. 1 newsmaker are as frosty as the polar vortex.

Feisty sparring by Nolan Finley and Detroit Councilman George Cushingberry began Tuesday and continued daily through Thursday. A side-by-side look at the combatants is in a grid display below. 

After three public rounds, you're invited to score the match in terms of verbal dexterity, counter-punches, originality and any other factors that come to mind. Here's a recap of action so far:

  • Round 1: "The council could only have made a worse choice [for president] in George Cushingberry Jr. — an old-school political operative and former Wayne County commissioner and state representative. And while council didn’t choose him as president, it offered Cushingberry the No. 2 position." -- Finley in editorial Tuesday
     Counter-punch“Dear Detroit News, Go to hell. Go straight to hell. Do not pass go and don't even think about collecting $200. Jones and Cush will lead the Push for an even Greater Detroit. #WeLoveDetroit” -- Cushingberry in online comment under editorial that morning
  • Round 2: "Go to hell Nolan Finley and we will prove you all very wrong!" -- Cushingberry on Facebook Wednesday
  • Round 3: "We can take it. What we can’t take is the real likelihood that Cushingberry and crew will continue the Detroit City Council tradition of taking the city to hell. . . . George Cushingberry [is] a slick political operator who has had his snout in the public trough for nearly 40 years." -- Finley in column Thursday
    Counter-punch: "Dear Mr. Finley, you can sing your song, because Brenda and the Council will prove all of you wrong! Mike and Brenda will set a new agenda for the City of Detroit. #WeLoveDetroit more than you!" -- Cushingberry in comment under column

Whose jab is strongest? Who shows speed and agility?

Post a comment with your ringside rating, and tell whether the rivals should keep at it or move on.   

TALE OF THE TAPE
 
  Name   Nolan Finley   George Cushingberry
  Position   Detroit News opinion editor   Detroit City Council
  Age   58   61
  Birthplace   Cumberland County, Kentucky   Detroit
  High school   Garden City East   Cass Tech
  Current city   Livonia   Detroit
  Degrees   Schoolcraft College, Wayne State    Wayne State (2), University of Detroit
  Experience   Detroit News, 1976-present
  TV public affairs show host and contributor
  State House, 1975-83 and 2005-09
  Wayne County Board, 1983-99